I’v been thinking about the Graduate Tax; is it fairer than the student loan process?
Ideally, it would be popular - and a good idea - if we could get rid of the student charging idea - back to the old system where higher education was paid for through general taxation and student grants were available as appropriate. But this was a system for a time when only about 2 per cent of the population went to higher education. If you want to increase that percentage (which has happened) then, the argument goes, the burden on the tax payer is too much. This cannot be a right/wrong answer - it’s a matter of choice or priorities when balancing the UK’s budget.
The next thing to add into the mix is the pressure universities feel on their own bank balances and the need for enough money to manage, effectively, their programmes. They are already making swingeing cuts to staffing and other areas, and must be nearing the level when student experience is affected. There is little doubt that the cap on student fees will be raised or removed in the near future. Universities will feel a great pressure to increase fees, or to vary fees according to courses in order to maximise income. So if a course is popular, the fees are likely to go up.
With variable course fees we are then in a difference set of circumstances. What will be the effect of variable fees on people’s choices relating to economic and social backgrounds? Under the student loan system, students will know what they have to pay back (it will be finite) so the effect of variable fees may be exacerbated. The big advantage of a graduate tax is that the notion of a debt is removed from the student - and that’s a big advantage. But the relationship between the graduate tax element and the student fee is now brought up front; so will the graduate tax be unfair in as much as students on lower cost courses will be subsidising students from higher feed courses?
Or will the graduate tax itself be variable - or capped at the point at which the student fees are paid off? Now this sounds very much like the student loan process, except the loan is not carried by the student but by the country.
The graduate tax is attractive at first view, but I’m yet to be convinced. We await more details.
Theatre is Politics, Politics is Theatre. I'm fortunate to be involved in both - and in Education too. So this blog will cover thoughts on all of these. Is it naive to want to make the world a better place? The title is a shortened version of one of my guiding principles . . . The artist is the mirror, watchdog and critic of society. That's why we must support artists - even when they criticise us.
Showing posts with label graduate tax. Show all posts
Showing posts with label graduate tax. Show all posts
Friday, 1 October 2010
Friday, 16 July 2010
Cable can float it - but will it sink?
Vince Cable has floated the possibility of the ‘graduate tax’; that people who have obtained degrees will pay a higher rate of tax in order to repay the cost of their tuition.
During the course of yesterday, and in a series of interviews, the policy seemed to develop . . . That there might be an eventual cap on the total amount paid . . . That the money might be ring-fenced by HMRC to go back into HE. But Cable and his colleagues, in the main, refused to answer any seriously probing questions on the basis that we ‘don’t want to preempt any of the findings of the review into HE funding.’ (Other questions included ‘What happens to graduates who leave the UK?’ and ‘What about students who come from EU Member States?’)
Implicit in this proposal is the principle of the Treasury ring-fencing money - that is, the extra graduate tax income must go straight back to HE funding. This is a principle the Treasury avoids like the plague - if they start it for one department, the pressure is on to do it for others . . .
If Cable and his government colleagues aren’t prepared to answer questions, why trumpet the policy? What we have is another half-baked idea from this present coalition government. So why rush forwards with a plan so ill thought-through?
A lot has to do with where Cable is coming from.
Tony Blair introduced the Student Loan repayment system because his government vastly expanded the number of students going into HE. The cost of this education had to be paid for. In opposition the LibDems took the comfortable position of saying they would abolish tuition fees . . . safe in the knowledge that they would never be in a position to implement it. But now they find themselves tied into a Government that is likely to agree to a removal of a cap on fees - almost the opposite of their chosen position.
The LibDems gained great support from student rich constituencies in the General Election. They calculated this . . . and sadly many student fell for the cynical (if effective) ploy. LibDem MPs now find themselves in a potentially difficult position. Abstentions may have been made available, but they’re not face-saving enough. Cable - and in generous moments I have to feel sorry for the guy - finds himself in the position of having to square a circle.
Since I used to teach maths I can tell you that you can’t square a circle . . . which is a regular polygon with an infinite number of straight sides - a square having four. But you probably already knew that.
During the course of yesterday, and in a series of interviews, the policy seemed to develop . . . That there might be an eventual cap on the total amount paid . . . That the money might be ring-fenced by HMRC to go back into HE. But Cable and his colleagues, in the main, refused to answer any seriously probing questions on the basis that we ‘don’t want to preempt any of the findings of the review into HE funding.’ (Other questions included ‘What happens to graduates who leave the UK?’ and ‘What about students who come from EU Member States?’)
Implicit in this proposal is the principle of the Treasury ring-fencing money - that is, the extra graduate tax income must go straight back to HE funding. This is a principle the Treasury avoids like the plague - if they start it for one department, the pressure is on to do it for others . . .
If Cable and his government colleagues aren’t prepared to answer questions, why trumpet the policy? What we have is another half-baked idea from this present coalition government. So why rush forwards with a plan so ill thought-through?
A lot has to do with where Cable is coming from.
Tony Blair introduced the Student Loan repayment system because his government vastly expanded the number of students going into HE. The cost of this education had to be paid for. In opposition the LibDems took the comfortable position of saying they would abolish tuition fees . . . safe in the knowledge that they would never be in a position to implement it. But now they find themselves tied into a Government that is likely to agree to a removal of a cap on fees - almost the opposite of their chosen position.
The LibDems gained great support from student rich constituencies in the General Election. They calculated this . . . and sadly many student fell for the cynical (if effective) ploy. LibDem MPs now find themselves in a potentially difficult position. Abstentions may have been made available, but they’re not face-saving enough. Cable - and in generous moments I have to feel sorry for the guy - finds himself in the position of having to square a circle.
Since I used to teach maths I can tell you that you can’t square a circle . . . which is a regular polygon with an infinite number of straight sides - a square having four. But you probably already knew that.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)